Jobe Watson injured as Essendon hangs on against gallant GWS
ESSENDON'S unconvincing season continues, stumbling its way to a 15-point victory over Greater Western Sydney that leaves the Bombers stuck outside the top eight at the halfway mark of the year.
The visitors did just enough to secure an 11.15 (81) to 9.12 (66) victory at Spotless Stadium that improves their record to 6-5 ahead of next week's clash with Melbourne at the MCG.
But the heavy favourites had to scratch and claw all night to get the better of the upstart Giants in a performance that does little to indicate they are a genuine finals threat in 2014.
It was an encouraging display from the home side, however, which took another step towards burying the memory of its dreadful defeats to West Coast and Richmond by a combined 224 points.
GWS bounced back from those horror shows with last week's narrow loss to Hawthorn at the MCG, maintaining that type of form with a combative showing on home soil on Saturday night.
The Giants threatened a major boilover when they kicked three straight goals midway through the final term to close to within a solitary point.
Despite the nature of the performance, Bombers coach Mark Thompson felt his side was always going to prevail.
"It's just your gut feel for what your players are capable of and what you've seen them do before," he said.
"We would've liked to have been 100 points in front, but we weren’t.
"We have good days and bad days.
"We weren't jumping out of our skin and when that happens, it's good to win still.
"I don't become super critical and over analyse little things."
David Zaharakis was brilliant for Essendon, vying with GWS veteran Heath Shaw for best-on-ground honours.
Watson, Dyson Heppell and Brendon Goddard were also prominent, while Joe Daniher was wasteful in front of goal, finishing with 3.4.
Shaw was outstanding in defence for the home side, with Shane Mumford tireless in the ruck and Callan Ward, Devon Smith, Adam Treloar and Dylan Shiel leading the way through the midfield.
Treloar led the GWS goalkicking with three.
It was a hotly contested game from the opening bounce, with GWS debutant Rory Lobb lining up on 388-gamer Dustin Fletcher in surely one of the biggest disparities in experience the competition has seen.
But the rookie was up for the fight, taking some strong grabs and nailing a set shot with his first kick as the home side got off to a strong start.
Greasy conditions had players regularly losing their footing, but it was a willing opening term, which ended with the Bombers kicking three goals to GWS' two.
There were plenty of turnovers, but both clubs were up for the fight.
GWS kicked the first two goals of the second term to get its nose in front for the first time before the visitors lifted late, taking a 10-point advantage into the main break.
Essendon then managed to lift another notch in the third term, finally earning some scoreboard pressure and taking a 20-point lead into the fourth quarter.
There was some feeling just prior to the penultimate siren, with Davis Myers throwing a cheeky, totally unnecessary elbow at Devon Smith, sparking a melee during the break.
It will get looked at by the Match Review Panel, but Smith did appear to make the most of minimal contact.
The Giants then got on a roll early in the fourth quarter as the upset burst into view, yet it was the more experienced Bombers doing just enough to seal the four points.
"We all want to win games, but as I said to our players after the game, I'd prefer to have effort than composure at this stage," he said.
"It was probably a bit of composure in the last quarter where we were going inside 50 and threatening to take the lead where we needed to make some better decisions.
List analysis: Where your club ranks for age and experience
Who has the oldest list, who has the youngest, and which club has the most experience heading into 2025?
Dockers veterans face delayed pre-season after knee surgeries
Nat Fyfe and Michael Walters are expected to be fit for the start of the AFL season despite undergoing minor knee surgeries
Premiership Tiger handed suspension after assault charge
Noah Balta will sit out two pre-season matches and the first four games of the 2025 home and away campaign after being charged with assault
Opinion
Opinion
O'DRISCOLL: An ode to country footy and those who play it
She now plays at the highest level, but Fremantle's Emma O'Driscoll's love of the game started with running water for her local footy side in rural Western Australia. She reflects fondly on the role country footy plays in the fabric of Australia