What went right?

Liam Jurrah, a 20-year-old from remote Central Australia, became one of the stories of the season. The forward quickly dazzled the AFL with his aerial tricks and cat-like skills. He now looms as an integral part of Melbourne's future.

The 30-year agreement at Casey Fields was one of the club's most important off-field decisions. This facility and the building of a much-needed fan base in Melbourne's south-east are key strategic moves for the club.

The continuation of the Debt Demolition was a rousing success. Although Melbourne is still in the red, the past two legs of the campaign have raised more than $3.82 million, reducing the total debt to below $2 million. It is a considerable step in the right direction.

What went wrong?

The news of Jim Stynes' illness put all things associated with the game into perspective. One of Melbourne's favourite sons, the president and 1991 Brownlow Medallist is battling cancer, but his towering strength remains an inspiration.

In this era of drafting, claiming the wooden spoon doesn't carry the same stigma as previous years. Although not unexpected, due to the rebuilding of its list, it is still a disappointing result for Melbourne to finish 16th for the second year running.

After a promising pre-season, injuries again became an issue. Although Melbourne regained several players in late May, it went pear-shaped in the second half of the season. For the final five rounds, Melbourne had 17 players or more sidelined. 

Most valuable player

For varying reasons, Brad Green, Cale Morton and even Jack Watts have their claims, but it's hard to go past Aaron Davey. He took his game – and leadership – to another level. His foot skills were exquisite and his ability to influence a game was telling.

Coach's award for one-percenters

'Old' James McDonald (he turns 33 in October) has provided excellent leadership in his first season as captain, although his recognition has largely been internally. He is unassuming publicly, but has had a considerable influence on the inside. His tackling has again been strong, averaging just a touch under five per match. 

Needs a big pre-season

Key forward Michael Newton is contracted for 2010, having signed a two-year deal last year, but he needs to step-up considerably next season. Newton has immense talent, yet he has played just 21 matches in five seasons. There are opportunities for talls in Melbourne's attack, the question is: can he take it?

Overall grade: D

The views in this story are those of the author and not necessarily those of the clubs or the AFL.